Skip to main content
TapTax

VAT Return Software: What You Are Actually Paying For

Most VAT return software charges sole traders for features they will never use. Here is how to cut through the noise and pick what actually works.

By TapTax Team

8 min read

On this page10 sections

April came and went, and suddenly every software vendor in the UK is a Making Tax Digital expert. But if you registered for VAT before you registered for MTD for Income Tax, you have been living with VAT return software for years already. So why does it still feel like pulling teeth?

The Problem Nobody Admits

VAT return software is not complicated in principle. You record sales and purchases, apply the correct VAT rate, and submit a nine-box return to HMRC every quarter (or monthly, if you have opted in or HMRC has insisted). That is it. Nine boxes. A single-page summary.

Yet the software industry has built cathedrals around this nine-box church. FreeAgent, QuickBooks, Xero and Sage all offer VAT filing as part of subscription packages that cost anywhere from £15 to well over £80 a month once introductory discounts expire. If you are a sole trader turning over £60,000 a year, you are potentially spending £960 a year on software whose VAT functionality you could replicate in a well-structured spreadsheet, if only HMRC's MTD for VAT rules did not require a digital link between your records and the submission.

That digital link is the crux. It is also, conveniently for software vendors, the thing that forces you to pay.

VAT Return Software
Any HMRC-recognised application that maintains digital VAT records and submits the nine-box VAT return directly to HMRC via their API. Under Making Tax Digital for VAT, sole traders must use such software; spreadsheets are permitted only when combined with a compliant bridging tool that creates the digital link to HMRC.

MTD for VAT Has Been Live Since 2019. MTD for Income Tax Since April 2026.

a wooden table topped with papers and a pen - Photo by 2H Media on Unsplash
a wooden table topped with papers and a pen - Photo by 2H Media on Unsplash

It is worth separating these two things cleanly, because the software market lumps them together in ways that serve vendors more than sole traders.

Making Tax Digital for VAT has applied to virtually all VAT-registered businesses since April 2022. If your turnover is above the £90,000 registration threshold (as of 2026/27), you have been using HMRC-compliant VAT return software for years. If you registered voluntarily below the threshold, the same rules apply.

Making Tax Digital for Income Tax is a different obligation, live since 6 April 2026 for sole traders and landlords with qualifying income over £50,000. Under MTD for Income Tax, you submit quarterly updates of income and expenditure, then file your annual tax return by 31 January after the tax year ends. That tax return has not gone away; it has simply moved inside your MTD software.

The reason this matters for VAT return software is simple: if you are now inside MTD for Income Tax as well as MTD for VAT, you need a tool that handles both. Running two separate bits of software creates the kind of double-entry bookkeeping that software was supposed to eliminate.

£90,000

VAT registration threshold in 2026/27

9 boxes

Fields in a standard UK VAT return

£400

Typical annual cost of mid-tier VAT software after discounts expire

What VAT Return Software Actually Does (and What It Does Not)

Before you buy anything, it helps to strip the marketing down to what the software genuinely does for you.

What it must do (the non-negotiables)

  • Maintain a digital record of your VAT transactions
  • Calculate the nine boxes of your VAT return from those records
  • Submit the return to HMRC via the official API
  • Receive and store HMRC's confirmation

That is the entire legal requirement under VAT Notice 700/22. Everything else, automatic receipt scanning, project tracking, payroll, cash flow forecasting, is bolt-on.

What it does not need to do

  • Connect directly to your bank account. A CSV import of your bank statement achieves the same reconciliation. TapTax, for instance, supports CSV imports with presets for 16 UK banks, covering the vast majority of sole traders without requiring a live connection.
  • Send invoices. Invoicing and VAT filing are separate functions; bundling them together drives up cost.
  • Run payroll. As a sole trader you do not pay yourself a salary, so payroll modules are irrelevant unless you employ staff.
  • Forecast your business finances. Useful, but not what you are paying compliance software for.

If a sales rep is pitching you on features you will never use, that is the first sign the price is not right for your situation.

The Bridging Software Option

There is a cheaper route that is entirely legal and genuinely used by thousands of sole traders: bridging software.

If you already keep your records in a spreadsheet (or accounting software that does not have a direct HMRC connection), bridging software sits in between. You export your VAT figures into it, it creates the required digital link, and it files the nine-box return to HMRC. Tools in this category typically cost £10-£20 a year, a fraction of full accounting software.

The trade-off is friction. You are maintaining records in one place and filing from another. For a sole trader with straightforward VAT affairs, that is a minor inconvenience. For someone managing fifty purchase invoices a week across multiple VAT rates, it becomes a liability.

If your VAT affairs are simple, primarily standard-rated sales with a handful of zero-rated or exempt items, bridging software is worth serious consideration. If you are on the Flat Rate Scheme, the calculation is even simpler, and a bridging tool handles it comfortably.

The Flat Rate Scheme: A Special Case

woman sitting around table holding tablet - Photo by Brooke Cagle on Unsplash
woman sitting around table holding tablet - Photo by Brooke Cagle on Unsplash

Around a quarter of VAT-registered sole traders use the Flat Rate Scheme (FRS), and it is worth flagging that some software handles FRS better than others.

Under FRS, you pay HMRC a fixed percentage of your gross (VAT-inclusive) turnover rather than calculating input and output VAT separately. The percentage depends on your trade sector, ranging from 4% for certain retailers to 14.5% for IT consultants. The maths is simpler, but you need software that applies the correct sector percentage and flags the first-year 1% discount if you are newly registered.

Most full-service accounting tools support FRS correctly. Some bridging tools require you to do the FRS calculation manually before entering figures. Neither approach is wrong; just be clear which you are buying.

If you are unsure whether the Flat Rate Scheme still makes financial sense for your business, the VAT Returns and MTD: What Changes for Sole Traders in 2026 post covers the crossover in detail.

Why the Big Platforms Charge What They Charge

It is worth following the money for a moment, because understanding the incentive structure helps you shop more clearly.

Xero's UK revenue in its most recent published accounts was driven substantially by its SME subscription base, with average revenue per user growing year on year. QuickBooks' parent Intuit reported global revenue north of $16 billion in its 2024 financial year. These are not accounting tools subsidised by altruism; they are subscription businesses that need monthly recurring revenue.

HMRC, by contrast, chose not to build a free, government-owned MTD filing tool for sole traders. It mandated the use of commercial software instead, effectively handing the market to private vendors. The post Digital Tax Software: What HMRC Won't Build for Free explores that decision in more detail, but the short version is that sole traders are paying a compliance tax on top of their actual tax, and the size of that compliance tax depends entirely on which software they choose.

For a sole trader turning over £65,000, the difference between a £10/month bridging tool and a £35/month integrated platform is £300 a year. Over five years, that is £1,500 spent on features you may never open.

£300

Annual saving by choosing basic over mid-tier software

£1,500

Five-year saving over a £35/month subscription

4%

Lowest Flat Rate Scheme percentage (some retailers)

What Changes Now That MTD for Income Tax Is Live

Since April 2026, sole traders above £50,000 in qualifying income have been inside MTD for Income Tax as well as MTD for VAT. That changes the software calculus.

If you are running separate tools for VAT and income tax record-keeping, you are almost certainly duplicating work. Your sales invoices need to feed both your VAT return and your quarterly income updates. Your purchase records need to populate both your input VAT claim and your business expense totals.

The most efficient setup is a single tool that handles both. This does not mean the most expensive tool. It means a tool designed for the overlap, one that records transactions once, applies them to VAT periods and income tax periods simultaneously, and submits to HMRC without you re-entering data.

TapTax was built for exactly this overlap. You import your bank statement by CSV, categorise your income and expenses, and the software handles both your quarterly MTD income updates and your VAT return preparation in one place. No enterprise pricing, no modules you will never open.

For a fuller look at how integrated MTD software compares in practice, Top MTD Software Tested: What Sole Traders Actually Found is worth reading before you commit to any subscription.

Five Questions to Ask Before Buying VAT Return Software

1. Is it on HMRC's list of recognised software?

This is not optional. HMRC maintains a list of software compatible with MTD for VAT. If a tool is not on it, you cannot use it to file legally. The HMRC Recognised Software: What the Label Actually Means post explains how to verify this in under two minutes.

2. Does it handle both VAT and MTD for Income Tax?

If you are above the £50,000 qualifying income threshold, paying for two tools is wasteful. Ask explicitly whether the software covers both obligations under a single subscription.

3. What happens after the introductory discount?

Many platforms offer three months free or a heavily discounted first year. The real question is what you pay from month thirteen onwards. Get the full-price figure in writing before you commit.

4. Do you need a live bank connection, or will CSV import suffice?

Direct bank feeds are convenient but not essential. If importing a CSV from your bank once a month fits your workflow, you do not need to pay a premium for automatic transaction syncing.

5. Can you export your data if you switch?

Data portability matters. HMRC requires you to retain VAT records for six years. If your software locks your historical data behind a subscription, you will need to keep paying even after you switch. Always confirm you can export a full transaction history in a standard format.

People also ask

Do I need special software to file a VAT return in the UK?

Yes. Under Making Tax Digital for VAT, you must use HMRC-recognised software to maintain digital records and submit your return. Plain spreadsheets are not sufficient on their own, though a spreadsheet combined with a compliant bridging tool is permitted.

What is the cheapest way to file a VAT return under MTD?

VAT bridging software is the lowest-cost compliant option, typically costing £10-£20 a year. You keep records in a spreadsheet, then use the bridging tool to file the nine-box return to HMRC. This works well for sole traders with straightforward VAT affairs.

Can I use the same software for VAT and MTD for Income Tax?

Yes, and if your qualifying income exceeds £50,000 you should, since MTD for Income Tax has been mandatory since April 2026. Using one tool for both avoids double-entry and reduces the chance of your VAT figures and income figures diverging.

How long do I need to keep VAT records under MTD?

HMRC requires you to keep VAT records digitally for six years. Make sure any software you choose allows you to export a full transaction history in case you switch providers before that period is up.

The Bottom Line

a calculator and a pen sitting on top of a piece of paper - Photo by Aaron Lefler on Unsplash
a calculator and a pen sitting on top of a piece of paper - Photo by Aaron Lefler on Unsplash

Remember the question at the start: why does VAT return software still feel like pulling teeth? Usually because you are using software sized for a business three times larger than yours, paying for a payroll module you will never open, a cash flow dashboard you glance at twice a year, and a client portal that has nothing to do with submitting nine boxes to HMRC.

VAT return software has one job. The best tool for a sole trader is the one that does that job, connects it cleanly to your MTD for Income Tax obligations, and costs you the least per month after the introductory period expires. For most tradespeople and freelancers earning between £50,000 and £80,000, that is not Xero Enterprise. It is something lighter, purpose-built, and priced for the person doing it alone.

If you are shopping right now, start by confirming the tool is on HMRC's recognised software list, ask what the year-two price is, and check whether one subscription covers both your VAT return and your quarterly MTD income updates. Answer those three questions and the choice narrows considerably.

File your MTD quarterly updates in minutes

TapTax imports your bank statements, categorises expenses automatically, and submits to HMRC with a tap. Free plan, no card required.

Start free

Frequently asked questions

Can a sole trader use bridging software for MTD for VAT in 2026/27?

Yes. HMRC permits bridging software as a compliant method for MTD for VAT, provided there is a digital link between your records and the submission tool. You maintain records in a spreadsheet or other software and use the bridging tool to file. It is typically far cheaper than full accounting platforms.

What is the difference between VAT return software and MTD for Income Tax software?

VAT return software handles the nine-box quarterly VAT submission to HMRC. MTD for Income Tax software handles quarterly updates of income and expenses plus the annual tax return. Since April 2026, sole traders above £50,000 need both; using one integrated tool avoids duplicating your record-keeping.

Does VAT return software need to connect directly to my bank account?

No. A direct bank connection is a convenience feature, not a legal requirement. Importing a CSV bank statement achieves the same reconciliation and is sufficient for the digital link HMRC requires under MTD for VAT.

How do I check if my VAT return software is HMRC-recognised?

HMRC publishes a list of software compatible with Making Tax Digital for VAT on its website. Search for 'Find software that's compatible with Making Tax Digital for VAT' on GOV.UK. Any tool not on that list cannot be used to file legally under MTD for VAT.

Is VAT return software suitable for sole traders on the Flat Rate Scheme?

Most HMRC-recognised VAT software supports the Flat Rate Scheme, applying your sector percentage to gross turnover rather than calculating input and output VAT separately. Check that the software allows you to set your specific FRS rate and applies the first-year 1% discount if you are newly registered.

TopicsVAT return softwareMaking Tax DigitalMTD for VATsole traderHMRC compliance
ShareXLinkedIn

Written by

TapTax Team

The team that builds TapTax

TapTax builds Making Tax Digital software for UK sole traders and landlords. Our guides explain HMRC rules in plain English, with the sources linked so you can check them.

  • TapTax is HMRC-recognised.
  • Founded by Solomon Amos, who built its HMRC integration

Published

About TapTax

Free calculators for the figures this article talks about.

Stop dreading your tax return.

TapTax imports your bank statements, categorises expenses automatically, and submits quarterly updates to HMRC. Free plan, no card required.

Get started free